People search · 6 min read

How to background check a nanny or caregiver, legally

Short answer

Hiring a nanny, sitter or home caregiver is employment. If you use a background check company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires a separate written disclosure, the candidate's written permission, and specific notices before and after any decision based on the report. You can still check references, licenses and public registries yourself.

What the FCRA requires

  1. Use a consumer reporting agency (an FCRA-compliant background screening company), not a people-search site.
  2. Give the candidate a clear written disclosure, in a document by itself, that you will get a report.
  3. Get their written permission.
  4. Before deciding not to hire based on the report, give them a copy of the report and the FCRA summary of rights, so they can correct errors.
  5. After the decision, send an adverse action notice with the screening company's contact details.

Source: FTC, Background checks: what employers need to know. Some states add their own rules.

Confirm the candidate's identity

Private search. Nobody is notified.

What you can check yourself

  • References: call them yourself; ask specific questions about reliability and safety.
  • Identity: does the name, photo and phone number line up across public profiles?
  • The national sex offender registry at NSOPW.gov.
  • Certifications: CPR/first aid cards, nursing licenses on Nursys, or a home care agency's state license.
  • Driving: if they will drive your children, a driving record check through a screening company (FCRA applies).

Red flags

  • Unwilling to consent to a background check.
  • References who are only reachable by text or cannot be verified.
  • Overpayment or "send me a check first" schemes on caregiver job boards are common scams too.

Questions

Can I use a people-search site to screen a nanny?

No. Using people-search results to make a hiring decision falls under the FCRA. Use an FCRA-compliant screening company with the candidate's written permission.

Know who you are dealing with

Search a name, phone number or email to see public profiles and records.

Sources

Keep reading

Published 2026-10-28 by the TrueSearch Safety Team. General information, not legal advice. In an emergency call 911.

TrueSearch is not a consumer reporting agency as defined by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Do not use TrueSearch or anything on this page to make decisions about employment, housing or tenant screening, credit, insurance, or any other FCRA-covered purpose. Results come from publicly available information and licensed telecom data and may be incomplete or out of date.